Miller, Tom, and Parker, Dee (1997). Writing for the Reader: A Problem-Solution Approach
In the article “Writing for the Reader: A Problem-Solution Approach written by Tom Miller and Dee Parker, I think we can identify the structure an article should have, some aspects the writer should follow when writing; in this case, we have the example a “Forum” article. Based on Swales (1992) and Hoey’s (1981) approaches, the article shows us a structure to follow, explaining each step: the situation, the problem, the solution and the evaluation. It seems that this structure should be very useful for readers and in this way I think they can become better critical thinkers.
For the introduction Swales (1992) considers the writer have to investigate, catch reader’s attention by writing articles that are really important for the audience around the world; Swales calls this “establishing a territory”. In addition, the reporter contributes wit the audience by giving possible solutions, Swales names this “establishing a niche” and at the end he considers the writer should give the steps to follow and solve the problem.
Moreover Swales and Hoey’s (1981) approaches are quite similar, just by adding one more step called evaluation. It could be a positive or negative evaluation and when it is negative a new situation appears. A clear example of Forum articles is given in which it is explained step by step and in this way we can analyze the structure, so in my opinion it is easier to understand and analyze Swale’s and Hoey’s structures.
In the problem, the author expresses he is interested in the problem as well as the reader and s/he gives specific details. For example the topic of Janet Niederhauser’s article introduces to the readers what is the article about and while reading people can identify the causes of low motivation. Sentences include cause words and there is a sequence between them. For the solution Niederhauser’s guides readers in the very beginning and to give the solutions she substitutes negative words for positives; in other words, the article changes and the final result is an active and positive article which persuades the reader’s mind.
The conclusion is a short description of the article and the writer can give an example trying to convince reader’s mind. It is very important to catch reader’s attention. Headings and initial sentences keep people reading and the connection between sentences and paragraphs make readers understand the problem(s) they would find in the article and at the end they will find solutions. At the end of the article the main purpose of the writer must be to change reader’s mind trying to change their attitude and become critical thinkers because through reading people learn, discuss and enrich their criteria.